Double standards? CCTV affordable, FOI not?

Something to look forward to: Our Chief Minister is to report back to Tynwald on the topic of Freedom of Information. I’m sure we all feel that accessing information about how our money is spent is essential. However, Mr Bell referred to cost issues when the introduction of an FOI was mentioned in Tynwald. He suggested that it appeared to be a costly venture for the Channel Islands and left us with the impression that should the implementation of the act cost millions, it would not be feasible in the current financial climate.

Perhaps he has a point. After all, having been starved of information for so long there could well be a public stampede to obtain information from the FOI department. But I doubt it. In order to assess the implications of the costs accurately we need to look at costs of surveillance island-wide over the last few years in comparison. It is clear that very few query the cost of CCTV (notable exception Councillor Richard Kissack) and surveillance equipment. CCTV always seems to be a priority and costs don’t really appear to be an obstacle. Yet after many years of dilly-dallying the subject of FOI was introduced at the very last minute in the last term of government, thus proving that the promise had been upheld while also making it impossible to pass legislation at that late stage.

When FOI was mentioned in the autumn the reference to possible prohibitive costs prevented the topic from being further pursued until the projected outlay could be assessed. Now amid cost-slashing measures, redundancies and reduced services it would be particularly easy to dismiss this as an unaffordable luxury. However, many see this as a necessity, not a luxury. How can we possibly know how our money is being spent if there is no insight into the processes and outgoings of government. If, for instance, huge sums are being spent on spying on the general public in everyday life we need to why know this is.

It appears to be another case of double standards. No expense spared on surveillance but cost becomes the prime issue when the public would like to see what government is up to. We would of course need to be able to verify the projected costs to ascertain how accurately the sums have been done. Can we do that without an FOI? Whatever the outcome one thing is certain: We can’t afford any further surveillance of the general public. When FOI is being queried, we simply can’t afford any further snooping. Sorry guys  – the CCTV business is a no-no now.

And if you would like more idea of what goes on in Douglas Council proceedings, please refer to the following comment, and make your views known:


2 comments on “Double standards? CCTV affordable, FOI not?

  1. As you rightly imply, the State can collect information about the public but without FOI legislation we in the Isle of Man have no right to ask about the decisions taken by the State.
    Listen carefully and dissect what Chief Minister Bell says about FOI when he makes his statement.
    It is Item 3 on the Tynwald Agenda.
    The focus will be on the Budget (Tuesday 21st February) so those of us who care about FOI need to make sure that the statement is not lost in the hot air generated over that.
    It amazes me why our local media has not been badgering for the FOI Act

  2. Are you absolutely sure that we have a local media? Is there a locally owned and controlled media that is in a position to say something the powers that be do not like?

    Try getting an article published on any of the following

    vulnerable people being over medicated
    children in care being suicidal or being abused
    police brutality or corruption or dishonesty

    You should not find it too difficult to find an elderly person with a big pile of pills to take, try getting some publicity for the ‘medication’ they are on!!!!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s